In fact, the stars were even engaged at one point.

But their relationship played out like an episode straight out of a soap opera.

With whom did Sheridan allegedly cheat?

Nicollette Sheridan and Michael Bolton cuddle on red carpet

If you guessed Bolton, you’d be right.

Taking to Twitter, the actorcommented, “Re Fake News!

What’s it called when your wife of one year suddenly goes to bed with a pop singer?

Lisa Rinna and Harry Hamlin smile together at event

…two weeks after your mother dies??

We may never know the truth or exactly how Sheridan and Bolton met in the ’90s.

It’s also unclear why they ended their relationship the first time.

Nicollette Sheridan and Michael Bolton at 2006 Golden Globe awards

The singer had recently said about his relationship with Sheridan, “I am very committed.

It is a very special time in my life.

I have a good feeling about the future.”

They appreciate your respect for their privacy in this matter” (viaReuters).

So what went wrong the second time?

He added there would always be “certain people you’re always gonna love.”

He was complimentary of his ex, and noted their romance “ran its course” (viaMeaww).