For well over a decade, two of music’s biggest superstars were embroiled in a feud.

“Since when has lip-synching been live?

“That’s me off her Christmas card list, but do I give a toss?

Elton didn’t seem to be over it, though.

“She came in, and I sent over a note.

She was very gracious,” he said during an interview with Terri Seymour ofExtra.

“I apologized profusely because what I said should have never appeared in public.”

Madonna accepted the apology, and then Elton bought her dinner.

“She was fantastic.

She was just like, ‘Okay, let’s get a move on.'”