Celebrity pairingsdon’t always make sense, which is part of the fun of obsessing over every little detail.

But they were indeed together for a short while in the mid-2010s.

Looking back on their relationship now, it seems utterly of its time.

Julia Stiles and David Harbour pose on the red carpet together

Of course, the reasons behind their split are unknown.

Breakup dates, meanwhile, differ with guesses as far-reaching as 2012 and 2015.

Both have since settled down with other people.

Julia Stiles and David Harbour look lovingly at each other

If nothing else, we can bask in the knowledgeKat Stratfordonce dated Chief Hopper.