For years, tabloids and fans alike have speculated about whoJennifer Anistonwas dating.

Aniston then replied, “Nah.

Despite their obvious chemistry, it wasn’t meant to be between Rudd and Aniston.

Paul Rudd and Jennifer Aniston smiling

The two first met in 1995 when Yaeger was working for Rudd’s new publicist.

Yaeger and Rudd share two kids, a son named Jack and a daughter named Darby.

And as pretty much everyone in the world knows, Aniston was headed towards her romance with Brad Pitt.

Paul Rudd and Jennifer Aniston promoting “The Object of My Affection” in 1998

The two would go on their first date in 1998 before marrying in 2000 (viaMarie Claire).