However, Hart still appeared in the music video.
Many fans have wondered howPinkand Hart handled being on set together while they were separated.
“I don’t really explain it to him.

I don’t think he’s actually listening,” Pink said with a wry smile.
“I don’t think he’s heard a single word I’ve said in 16 years.”
‘Cause I thought maybe he’d leave," Pink began.

She then decided to have a private discussion with the director, Dave Meyers.
“I was like, ‘Dave, play line three, then skip to line five.
Definitely do not play line 10.’
He’s like, ‘Uh, you want to do this piecemeal?’
Many fans have argued that the “So What” music video is a testament to Pink’s strength.
Indeed, the pop singer confirmed in 2010 that she reconciled with Hart after the separation.
The couple has stayed together ever since and share two children, Willow and Jameson, viaUS Weekly.
“They want it to be new.
And I understand that.
But for me, I’m a creature of habit.
I love looking at my history in the face of [Carey].
And when he says, ‘Remember that one time?’
and it’s like, a 12-year-ago memory, I love that.”